FORGET HISTORY

The inspiration for this blog came in part from John Sayles’ wonderful 1995 film, Lone Star.  Set in a small Texas city, with Anglo, Mexican-American, and African-American populations, the story segues from the past to the present and back again.  It portrays characters both as they are now and as they were in previous generations.  Good and evil deeds are unearthed.  The male protagonist, an honorable sheriff, discovers his father’s villainy, even though the father had helped overthrow an even worse sheriff before him.  We learn that an overbearing restaurant owner, who berates her Mexican staff for “not speaking English” and condemns “wet backs” who enter the United States against the law, crossed the Rio Grande illegally herself.  The female protagonist, her daughter and a teacher, ends the film by saying, “Forget the Alamo.”

     This sparked what I have been thinking about the Middle East, most particularly the Hamas-Israeli War.  History in that region goes back for millennia.  No one ever forgets the wrongs done to them in the past.  But this feuding prevents any solution today.  Here are two current examples.  What Hamas did to Israeli civilians –- killing and taking well over a hundred of them hostage –- was horrific.  But it was not a Holocaust, that is destruction or slaughter on a mass scale.  For Israelis and their government to call it that, as they have and continue to do, prevents any resolution of the conflict.

     Conversely, the oft-quoted Palestinian slogan, “From the river [Jordan] to the sea [the Mediterranean],” which refers to Palestinian territory, also implies that Israel, which occupies the same area, should not exist.  This saying also prevents any resolution of the current war.

     I have spent my life teaching and writing history.  I think historically and believe that people need to know history to understand the present.  But not in this case!  To resolve this horrible war, I believe history needs to be forgotten.  Instead of repeating old grievances, treat your opponents as human beings.  They have the same needs and emotions as you.  That is the only successful way to deal with this dreadful situation.  If Israelis conceive of this struggle as a “Holocaust,” they can ignore the discrepancy between the hundreds of Israelis Hamas killed and the tens of thousands –- many of them children – that they have.  If Gazans keep declaring “From the river to the sea,” they give tacit approval to eradicating Israel completely.       

     Instead, I believe that both sides need to forget history and focus on the present.  Treat your opponents as human beings, as human as you yourselves are.  I think that will provide the only possible solution to this ghastly war.